I am fascinated by the words and metaphors poets and writers use to describe human emotion. Since college I have been a huge Bob Dylan fan, mainly because I love to get lost in the images he paints in his ballads, which so often are about sad characters telling tales of raw pain and regret. One of my favorites is found in the song, “You’re a Big Girl Now,” from the 1975 Blood on the Tracks album.  To me, no words better describe a person’s feelings of helplessness, despair and yes, I’ll say it again, raw pain, of when a spouse of many years decides to pull the plug on a marriage.

When Bob sings, “I’m going out of mind, oh, oh, with a pain that stops and starts, like a corkscrew to my heart,” I can say that I know what he’s talking about, and many of the men and women who come into my office facing similar situations do, too.
 
As a therapist, I often sit with these people as they feel that corkscrew through their heart, and wish that somehow I could reach over and surgically remove that pain, although I know I can’t. What I know is that people who are feeling like that are passing through a doorway that will take them to the five stages of grief, and over the next (at least) two years they will randomly pass through denial, bargaining, sadness and depression, anger and acceptance. And acceptance doesn’t mean you don’t feel the pain and hurt anymore, it just means you accept that the person is out of your life and isn’t coming back, so it’s going to be a tough road.

The only good thing I know about going through that process is that this sort of grief is what creates empathy and compassion. There is no way any of us can go through that sort of situation and not come out the other side a deeper, wiser, and more caring individual. I know in my case, after having gone through it, when I hear that anyone I know is getting a divorce, I always call the person frequently and invite him or her to get together – let’s go out, hang out, do something – even if it is just an acquaintance. I offer a safe place where they can talk about what they’re going through, and will never tell them to shut up, change the subject, let it go, or get over it.  I do that because no one knows like someone who has been there that a person whose spouse has left the marriage is experiencing loneliness to the 10th degree, and would be the first to let it go and get over it if only he or she could. These people need angels to reach out to them, and who don’t judge them for the sad state in which they find themselves.

Although I believe Bob Dylan is the master of describing the phenomenon we go through when a spouse leaves, I am wondering how those of you who have been through it would describe it. I also wonder how you got through it, and what words of wisdom you would say to those who will be entering through that doorway in the days, weeks, and months to come.

Here are the lyrics to Dylan’s song … what would be your lyrics?

You’re a Big Girl Now
by Bob Dylan

Our conversation was short and sweet.
It nearly swept me off-a my feet.
And I’m back in the rain, oh, oh,
And you are on dry land.
You made it there somehow
You’re a big girl now.

Bird on the horizon, sittin’ on a fence,
He’s singin’ his song for me at his own expense.
And I’m just like that bird, oh, oh,
Singin’ just for you.
I hope that you can hear,
Hear me singin’ through these tears.

Time is a jet plane, it moves too fast
Oh, but what a shame if all we’ve shared can’t last.
I can change, I swear, oh, oh,
See what you can do.
I can make it through,
You can make it too.

Love is so simple, to quote a phrase,
You’ve known it all the time, I’m learnin’ it these days.
Oh, I know where I can find you, oh, oh,
In somebody’s room.
It’s a price I have to pay
You’re a big girl all the way.

A change in the weather is known to be extreme
But what’s the sense of changing horses in midstream?
I’m going out of my mind, oh, oh,
With a pain that stops and starts
Like a corkscrew to my heart
Ever since we’ve been apart.

Dear Doctor Becky,

I am 50 and I’ve been dating a 57-year-old man for two months who absolutely refuses to be introduced as my BOYfriend. Also, he dislikes the terms dating and going steady for people our age,  saying the terms are juvenile. My question is, are there terms along these same lines that are more appropriate for the “older folk?”

Signed,

Not that old … yet.

Dear Not Old Yet,

Sounds like your beau has one of two problems … either he isn’t as committed to the relationship as you are or want him to be, and, therefore, cringes at the thought of being described as your boyfriend, OR  he truly believes there are a set of terms for the more mature set that describe dating and commitment.

If he falls into the first category, I urge you to not waste your time and to find a more suitable gentleman who cherishes you and feels lucky to have you in his life … and trust me, there are oodles out there who will.  You can tell who these guys are, because they will want to buy billboards and announce to the world via bullhorns and neon lights that they are your beau and yours alone. Most of these guys don’t care what term you use to describe your commitment, they just want you to use it. Life is truly too short to waste your time on a person who is not enthusiastic about you as his partner – don’t settle for less.

If he fall into the second category, then I wonder why words and terms are so important? Does it really matter if he is described as a boy or man friend?  If he embraces the relationship, then why not loosen up and accept a fun term such as BOYfriend or going steady?  Is it that he is nurturing a shallow sort of ego and cares about maintaining a suave and sophisticated public image?

In the end, if he wants to call his dedication to you a red three-sided horse’s hoof,  and refer to himself as your old man friend, paramour, Super Gramps, or Daddy-O, and what you’re doing together as going out, seeing each other, hanging out, or romantically involved, it’s less about the words than what the commitment is. I suggest you both sit down and come up with mutually acceptable words and phrasing and leave it at that.

Doctor Becky

When do people come in for counseling?? Typically they wait too long!! But the answer is, when they hit a wall, life isn’t working, and they’ve tried working it out on their own and it hasn’t worked. The person usually gets miserable enough for a voice to say loudly, "Dude, you need to call a therapist!" If I had it my way, though, people would come in before they reach that level of distress. Here are some questions I have developed for people to get a clearer understanding of whether or not it might be time to visit a professional counselor:

  • Do I know who the real me is?
  • Do I live life using a facade?
  • Am I afraid for people to know the real me?
  • Do I lead a joyful life?
  • Am I finding it difficult to pursue goals or to reach my potential?
  • Am I stressed, depressed, or unable to cope?
  • Do I have turmoil-filled relationships?
  • Do I feel fear, shame, doubt, guilt, anger over past issues?
  • Do I feel my life is not moving forward?
  • Do I make decisions in my life based on fear, shame, doubt, guilt and anger?
  • Have I lost the energy to do much of anything?
  • Do I involve myself in relationships that weigh me down instead of lift me up?
  • Do I feel I am not good/smart enough?
  • Am I unhappy in my relationships?
  • Am I unwilling to emotionally connect in relationships?
  • Am I afraid to be alone?
  • Do I stay in unhappy relationships because of my fear of being alone?
  • Do I do things to please others instead of myself?
  • Do I mold myself to be who others think I should be, instead of just showing the world the real me?
  • Do I have lots of ideas but little or no motivation or follow through?

In counseling school professors hammer into our head that all of us, even counselors, should be in therapy as part of an ongoing maintenance and accountability process – no, being in therapy is not correlated to being crazy or a nutcase, but it is correlated to being healthier mentally and physically. Even when my clients finish the bulk of their therapy, I tell them they’re not finished. Mental health is not a destination, it’s a journey, and all of us that have it have to stay on top of it and be mindful and consistent in order to keep it that way. After a person completes the bulk of his or her therapy, I ask them to come in at least once a month so that we can make sure they’re holding true to their new authentic and healthier self.

I’m wondering if anyone has any hesitation or biases about going to a mental health professional? Anyone had great experiences with it? Terrible experiences? Anything in between?