Counseling & Therapy for Individuals, Couples, & Families in Little Rock, AR. Find out when therapy is indicated, Becky's … Learn More
Setting Boundaries is the Ultimate Healthy Self Care.
I used to fear setting boundaries, but now I love it. Once I clearly understood when someone was out of line, I knew I was in the clear to set boundaries using the guidelines I mentioned below. Photo: Canva/Becky Whetstone
Having healthy boundaries with others is the most important skill we can learn, yet almost no one does it, at least properly. Why? Babies are born vulnerable with no ability to protect themselves, so our families protect us. If things had gone well, they would have taught us how to protect ourselves physically, mentally, and emotionally as we grew so that one day, when we’re on our own, we can protect ourselves. Because most of us grew up in families that did not have appropriate boundaries and did not teach us these things, the end result is the mess we see every day — absolutely zero knowledge of what they are and how to implement them. It is a huge reason, if not the main reason, why so many people and relationships stumble, crumble, and fall.
We will end all this today because I will teach you what they are. When you start practicing healthy boundaries, it will be the first step to having mental and emotional health once and for all.
What are Boundaries?
Boundaries are human beings’ way of protecting themselves. They are a security system that we use to prevent ourselves from verbally, physically, and emotionally harming other people and from them harming us. It is the most important form of self-care a human being can have. In my therapy sessions, at least half the conversations I have with people are centered around either the lack of boundaries their friends and family members have or my client’s inability to set boundaries. If you ever complain about something someone said or did, or they complained about you, then the chance of it being related to some failure of setting boundaries on either side is about 100 percent.
Andrea and Robert came to see me over issues in their marriage. After a couple of sessions, they were doing well, but for one issue, she says.
“Robert acts nasty with my family,” she says. “We all talk about how he can be when they come to stay with us or when we are on vacation together.”
“I can only take so much of your family, and when I’m done, I’m done,” he says.
After I asked a few questions and got some more information, the problem was clear: Andrea’s family is boundaryless, and Andrea had an aversion to setting limits with them.
I found out that Andrea’s biological family is all up in one another’s business all the time. They also love to do everything together and take it very personally when they aren’t invited on vacations with Andrea and her husband, Robert, which reveals a very immature and enmeshed family system. Robert likes her family; he doesn’t want to take every single vacation with them and doesn’t really want them to stay in their house for days or weeks when they visit from out of town. He says he probably wouldn’t mind very short overnight visits to their home or the occasional vacation together, but he resents that they expect the doors to their home to be open whenever they want, for as long as they want, and to be invited anytime they go anywhere on a trip.
Andrea says they had stopped inviting them on every trip after a recent dust-up, but her resistance to setting further boundaries centered around her parents babysitting for them anytime they go on a trip alone. She thinks accepting their generosity and then setting limits on other times when they visit the entire family or travel is ugly. She says they also need to stop accepting their babysitting benefits if they do end up setting boundaries with her family.
This was an extreme example of family boundary-setting problems. It was mind-boggling because both Andrea and Robert are highly educated individuals in high-powered jobs, but when it came to setting boundaries with her family, Andrea regressed to the age of a frightened little 7-year-old. What Robert was asking for was very reasonable, and since spouses should come before biological family, except in extreme cases, the answer to what to do was obvious. Still, the thought of setting any boundaries with her family was overwhelming, and Andrea wept, saying she would do it, but her family would be devastated and would take it very personally.
“Boundaries are how we take care of ourselves,” I said gently. “It’s self-care. Robert is trying to care for himself and manage his emotional well-being, and in this case, you need to have his back.”
If Andrea’s family had a healthy boundary system, the problem would never have existed. Instead, they have zero boundaries, and like a journalist with a press pass at a world leader summit, they want an all-access pass to anything they want to attend. It’s a form of entitlement, and people who feel entitled do not handle having that press pass limited or taken away very well. I warned Andrea about how ugly people with narcissistic tendencies can act when a boundary is set and that they are likely to finger-point back at the boundary setter and say things like, “Why are you being such a bitch?” or “Why are you being so mean?” Upon hearing that, she just put her head in her hands and wept again.
I also encouraged her to let her parents choose whether or not they want to continue babysitting moving forward instead of deciding for them.
Types of Boundaries.
There are two different types of boundaries: external, those involving the physical body, and internal, those involving the psyche. When it comes to the body, the proper distance for giving another personal space is to sit or stand at least two feet away, and a person is never touched without their permission. Never touch babies, things, pets, or adults without asking first.
Sex is a category that falls within the physical body boundary, and a person should be able to agree or not to have sex with another without experiencing a negative reaction. For example, if Sallie is bone-tired and doesn’t feel like having sex with her husband, Stan, tonight, she should practice self-care and tell him that she is too tired. Stan, in return, should be happy that Sallie takes such good care of herself. I wrote an entire blog about sexual boundaries recently. You can find it by clicking here.
People have the most difficulty with internal boundaries, those affecting how we think, feel, and act. The concept is very simple: Once we are grown, we have free will to do whatever we want. A person’s free will is like a human holy grail, and each of us needs to honor and revere it as the precious thing it is, meaning I must not mess with you doing as you please. There is a caveat, however: if we break laws or do things other people don’t appreciate, there may be consequences. If you do something I don’t like, I might set a boundary asking you not to do it, and you may or may not respect that boundary, but I also have the choice to create distance from or end relationships with those who don’t respect the clear boundaries I have just set.
Adults must not tell other adults what to think, feel, or do unless invited to do so. This is why someone trying to fix a problem we bring up or offer unsolicited advice can be so annoying; it’s a clear boundary violation.
In application, I cannot tell my husband or grown daughter what to do or what I think they should do unless they ask for my advice. If I have something that might be helpful to them, I must ask permission to tell them what it is. If they say no thanks, I must leave it be. I do have the right to make a request of anyone … I may request that my husband do something about his snoring. If my request is reasonable, which I think that request is, he should honor it. After all, if we are in a relationship with someone helping each other through life, what the heck are we doing without meeting one another’s reasonable requests?
Since we all are free to be our authentic selves and do life however we choose, this means you get to implement personal boundaries, such as not having to do things other people ask you to do unless you want to. I always tell clients this rule of thumb: Say yes to people if you can do it with a happy or neutral heart. A neutral heart means It might not be my favorite thing to do, but I don’t mind doing it. If you don’t want to do something or will resent the person if you do what they ask, then you must set a boundary and say no thanks. Self-care means protecting yourself from being miserable if at all possible. Remember that.
Codependent relationships and boundaries.
First, it’s important to know that I work from the Pia Mellody Facing Codependence model, not the one from Melody Beattie, the author of Codependent No More. Pia Mellody focuses on childhood developmental trauma, also known as complex trauma, and how almost all of us were traumatized numerous times in childhood, whether we remember it or not. Mellody says that once we are traumatized, we become emotionally disabled in five different areas, and area number two is boundaries.
Typically, we end up with a boundary system similar to the family we grew up in. And since people with complex trauma tend to be extreme one way or the other, this means you either grew up in a family with no boundaries at all, like Andrea’s and mine, or your family was walled off and emotionally unavailable. Part of codependent recovery is learning to have a healthy boundary system based on the external and internal boundary guidelines I laid out above. All a person has to do is learn and then start to practice the rules of external and internal boundary setting, and you’ll be on your way.
For those who are walled off and invulnerable, know that you can safely emerge from your emotional and physical bank vault by learning healthy boundary setting. You have to learn who is safe to be yourself with, come out of your box, and take chances on letting people in. If something comes up that harms you emotionally, you can protect yourself in the moment and then go back to being vulnerable again. nothing is sadder than someone who stays hiding on life’s sidelines because they don’t know how to protect themselves along the way. My method is to be out and vulnerable as a person who plays it pretty safe and doesn’t reveal risky things about myself. If I get to know you and learn to trust that you are safe, then I might relax completely and let you get closer. Each person has to work out a vulnerability policy that works for them. The author and sociology professor Brene Brown researches and writes about the necessity of courage and vulnerability; her work is profound and wonderful. I highly recommend it.
Speaking of courage, it takes courage to set boundaries, especially in the beginning, but this is what adulting is. Childish and immature adults are afraid to advocate for themselves, even when it’s entirely appropriate. When you start setting boundaries with people, they won’t like it, and you will likely be negatively judged. Yes, they will miss the old you who allowed them to take advantage or do whatever they wanted without being called out. Remember this: boundaries are for your own needs and protection. They are the most important form of self-care there is, and when managing emotional wellbeing, practicing self-care becomes numero uno among your priorities. Boundaries are vital and necessary for you to attain and maintain your emotional well-being. You will never have healthy relationships unless you learn to practice them.
Dealing with boundary offenders.
I’m sure that people who cannot restrain themselves boundary-wise have radar that helps them locate those with no boundary system. Before I learned to practice boundaries, I had none at all, and men in the workplace would take full advantage of my pleasing, non-confrontational self and touch, grab, hug, and say inappropriate things. I would smile while hating their guts, a sure sign that I was valuing their inner peace over my own and sabotaging my emotional well-being so those horny toads could be happy. Dear God, I was lost. We absolutely must put our mental and emotional needs over the wants and needs of others, but darn, it’s difficult to get people to do that.
Today, I don’t wait one second if someone is inappropriate in my presence. These days, the inappropriateness is more likely to be political, such as blatant racism, putting certain types of people down, or other controversial topics. People who bring up high-risk subject matter are boundary offenders, and when I hear it, I will speak out about it every time and respond respectfully and as an adult. I might say, “Not everyone thinks like you do, and I’d appreciate it if you’d either be respectful when speaking about your fellow humans or leave me out of the conversation.” Letting things slide enables boundary offenders.
On social media, you find a hornet’s nest of boundary offenders. There, under the cover of an anonymous name, people have no problem saying horrible, hateful things, telling lies, butting into your business, and telling you what an idiot you are. The ultimate boundary there is blocking people so you never have to encounter them again and sometimes even setting a post so that people aren’t allowed to comment. These are different times and boundary work is necessary no matter where you are, in person or on the Internet.
The boundary I haven’t mentioned.
Pia Mellody discusses speaking and listening boundaries, which are vital to learning how to be healthy with yourself and in relationships. I wrote a blog about this in August 2023; you can find it here.
Why boundaries exist.
Boundaries exist so we can have healthy relationships with ourselves and others. Unhealthy relationships almost always involve people with no personal limits or restraint boundaries preying on people with no protection boundaries, someone who is so walled off that emotional connection causes them tremendous anxiety so they retreat, people who feel entitled to do whatever they want, those who manipulate to make you feel guilty, and those who won’t take no for an answer. I have long hoped that the concept of boundaries and the negative consequences of not setting them would be taught in middle and high schools. It’s so important to emotional well-being and enjoying life. People need to learn to value and protect their inner peace. It’s okay to say no, it’s okay to live as you choose so long as you don’t harm others, and it’s okay to be you.
Hey, I’ve written a book about the marriage crisis dynamic and what to do when you’re in one. It will be published by HCI Books and will be out either in the fall or around January. I look forward to sharing my dream come true with you—stay tuned!
In the meantime, check out my new ebook on marriage crisis and how to know if you need to separate. It also includes a plan for an amicable divorce.
We’ve got lots of news and exciting things going on in the relationship realm … so I’m preparing to send out a regular newsletter with the best relationship advice on the planet. To get on my email list, click here.
Becky Whetstone, Ph.D., is a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist in Arkansas and Texas* and is known as America’s Marriage Crisis Manager®. She is a former features writer and columnist for the San Antonio Express-News and has worked with thousands of couples to save their marriages. She can work with you, too, as a life coach if you’re not in Texas or Arkansas. She is also co-host of the YouTube Call Your Mother Relationship Show and has a telehealth private practice as a therapist and life coach via Zoom. To contact her, check out www.DoctorBecky.com and www.MarriageCrisisManager.com. Also, here is how to find her work on the Huffington Post. Don’t forget to follow her on Medium so you don’t miss a thing!
For licensure verification, find Becky Whetstone Cheairs.
Waiting to Divorce Until Your Kids Are Grown is Misguided.
I’m on the warpath about relationship health, marriage messes and crises, separation, divorce, and all the ridiculous things people do to mess up their lives and other people’s lives. It has to stop; we must be better to ourselves and others and stop being such a misinformed and, many times, cruel species. I want to wave a wand over people’s heads and say, “Wake the hell up,” but I know that doesn’t work.
Maybe I should go the Neanderthal route and use a bat; there’s nothing wrong with fantasy … and if I did, no one needs one popped over their head more than the martyr-like man or woman who suffers in a marriage they plan to leave for years with minimal or no pro-active movement to fix or leave. Little or no addressing serious issues with their partner, just secret and mostly silent loathing, and … a conscious decision to divorce with a plan attached.
My brother was married for 22 years when his wife said she wanted to separate. He knew she had some issues with the marriage, but he didn’t know they were serious or that a definitive decision had been made and a marital death penalty was being delivered. In her separation conversation, she gave him hope that they could likely work things out with time and space. He worked on himself during that time, which was great, but the day never came when she wanted to work on things, and time dragged on. He realized at some point that she had no interest in reconciliation, found out she’d been having a long-term love affair, and had been miserable in the marriage and planning to divorce him for over seven years. He has never recovered from the rage he feels about that.
Even their almost-grown children were shocked when their mom kicked my brother out of the house. They had thought their parents’ marriage was one to be admired. My niece even wrote a book on marriage that talked about it, describing how affectionate her parents were up to the end and how it came out of the blue. The faux united front damaged my niece, causing her to wonder what was real. If her mother had thought she could slither out of the marriage quietly and without damage and drama by playing happy and misleading the entire family into thinking all was well until it wasn’t, she was wrong.
When a spouse like my brother realizes later what the real deal is, and they will, they will feel righteous anger. My brother was angry because he was kicked out of the family home and left in limbo when he could have been spending time healing and moving on. She got plenty of love and companionship while he spent days and nights alone. Her decision to keep him hanging prolonged his suffering and stole several years of what could have been. He felt he’d been played for a fool. Hell hath no fury like a spouse who has been played the fool, and this is the type of debacle I am trying to prevent.
Healthy people deal with issues as they come up. They don’t sit around and suffer, wring their hands, play games, lie, mislead, or manipulate. They do not scheme to leave their spouse in a few years, waiting for the moment their leaving won’t have such a negative impact, like when the youngest child has finally flown the nest (if they ever do), and wait for the day that there will be no child custody issues and child support won’t have to be paid. There is something about discontentment in marriage that causes people to keep most of their true feelings to themselves, though. (1) It’s a human phenomenon. Most people internalize and take themselves on thought journeys their spouse knows nothing about, subtracting points from their emotional bank account each time their partner gives them a difficult time, complains, fails to do something they said they would, makes a mistake, or creates a moment of exasperation. Some speak out and even ask to go to marriage therapy, but almost no one tells their partner clearly how seriously lethal their discontentment is or if they have a plan to divorce them when they are ready, when they find it suitable, and when they decide. I want to end this by teaching people that marriage dies in stages, and really, all relationships do. If you can identify these, then you will know exactly when you should have spoken up and gone for professional guidance together or on your own if your partner won’t go.
A marriage deteriorates in stages:
1. Disillusionment. Uh-oh, I think I’m unhappy. A person realizes they’re unhappy and tells themselves that relationships have ups and downs, and they’ll wait and see if this is serious.
2. Erosion. They realize it is serious and could lead to divorce but quickly dismiss the idea of divorce due to numerous concerns like children, finances, judgment, fear of failure, religious views, and more.
3. Detachment. The stock of the marriage drops further, and the unhappy spouse tells themselves they can hang on so long as they find things to sustain them away from the marriage, like hobbies, new friendships, affairs, physical activities, and going back to school. But the stock will continue to fall, and their ability to tolerate it will lessen.
4. The Straw. One day, we can’t predict when or how the unsuspecting spouse will say or do something or not say or do something. It could be something big or small, and at that moment, the disillusioned spouse gets absolute clarity: “I cannot be in a marriage where my spouse does X (the thing they just did).” The partner emotionally disconnects at that moment, and the ground is set for a marriage crisis.
When should a married couple go to a marriage counselor?
When a person hits stage two, erosion, a couple should get professional help. Almost no one does this, but they might if they had more knowledge and awareness of the marital deterioration process. Most divorces and marriage crises could have been averted in the long run if the couple had come in to deal with their issues early before the resentment and lack of trust had piled up. It is the marriage equivalent of catching cancer early.
I am fighting to end the passive-aggressive ways people deal with unhappiness in relationships. If your spouse’s stock is dropping, why wouldn’t you tell them? If you feel yourself disconnecting, what would prevent you from talking about it? If you’ve realized your marriage problems are serious and could lead to divorce, why would you stay silent? What is the aversion to being honest with your partner about what’s going on with you and your discontentment in the marriage? Why would you think it’s okay to decide to divorce and then keep that decision hidden in your vest for years?
The answer may be that you don’t want to start something. Heaven forbid that the family dust gets kicked up. Perhaps you fear your partner’s reaction; do you dread the amount of hostility you may encounter, for example? Some people tell me they tried, but their complaints fell on deaf ears. If I had a partner who was not responsive to my complaints, the deaf ears scenario, I would tighten the belt a little. People will wake up when they get uncomfortable enough; we must find out what that is for each person. What might be worth trying is moving out for a couple of weeks, going on strike in the form of things like refusing to attend important events, cooking dinner, or whatever it is your spouse values.
Most of us are wired to want to do right by people, to be good people. The only way to have integrity in this situation is to make the right decision and face your problem head-on like an adult. There is only one caveat to this: If your spouse is unstable or abusive, and you and your children’s well-being might be seriously endangered if you express your feelings and the intent to leave, then you should keep your plans secret and talk to a family violence center or call the family violence hotline at 800.799.SAFE (7233) about how to leave your partner safely. You will need support and they will help you.
Aside from instability and abuse, there is no excuse for doing the right thing. The more transparent and authentic people are, the healthier they are — please remember that.
What creates a marital martyr?
“My plan for a long time was to leave when our youngest child graduated from high school and left for college,” said Roy.”
“Why then?” I asked.
“I felt it was best for the kids to leave when I did. I’d been waiting a long time to catch my fresh start. To get away. I’d been miserable for years, and I would have guessed she was miserable, too. I thought I had picked the right moment to make my move and hoped for an amicable divorce, but it didn’t turn out that way. Sue was shocked and angry; she went ballistic, I mean, through the roof. She said that after all the years of marriage, she had no idea I was so unhappy. Everything went to hell. I thought the kids would be okay if I waited until they went to college, and that actually seems stupid now. I can’t believe the negative impact it had on them. Man, they turned on me, said they felt ambushed, too, and I basically blew up my entire life.”
Yes, a Decider, the person who plans to leave their spouse when the best time comes, doesn’t realize there is no best time to leave your spouse or your children. Like a martyr, they sacrifice themselves and their happiness on the altar of an intact family, at least while the children still live at home or whatever best time comes to mind. Attempts to repair their marriage along the way were lame at best, and they quickly gave up and slinked down into a marital foxhole, where they planned and plotted their escape.
Although these marital martyrs may tell a few choice confidantes or best friends that they plan to divorce their spouse “when the children graduate from high school” or whatever timeframe they choose that would allow them to be seen in the best possible light, the fact that they don’t clue their spouse in on where they are in the marriage is the most egregious act of all. If I were married to someone who did that and found out they were going through the motions of life and leading me to believe all was well, if not wonderful, while secretly watching the clock tick away and waiting for the alarm to go off, I wouldn’t be too happy about it, and that’s me being nice. My stance is: If you don’t want to be with me, don’t wait around thinking you’re doing me any favors; get yourself out the door so I can be around those who want me in their lives.
There is no nice and wonderful way to leave your family.
Your spouse will freak out no matter what day you tell them you are unhappy and want out. They will freak out even if they are unhappy, too. Your children will suffer, no matter how old they are or where they live. There is no right time or best time. If you have a person in mind to be with after you leave your original family, it is not likely your children will cope well that well, either. Children aged 12 and older feel disloyal to the biological parent who was betrayed and will find it hard to accept someone who played a part in that. Even if you find a partner who has nothing to do with your marriage ending, it will be difficult for your children to accept and adjust to it.
What your divorce fantasies are today will not match reality, I assure you. If you have never worked on your marriage, then you will not be able to say that you did everything you could to keep your family together. Being able to say that phrase brings those who divorce peace of mind in the end, “I did … all… I … could.” I always say a Decider must earn their divorce and new life if children are involved. If you want a family poop show and regrets, then don’t tell your spouse how seriously you’re struggling, don’t work on it, give up, walk away, and/or have an affair. If you want to earn your freedom with no stone left unturned and/or repair your marriage, then take the right path, get therapy for yourself and marriage therapy with your partner, and dedicate yourself to turning your dire situation around. Put the work in that it takes. If, after all the work, your marriage is still a source of misery, then we can talk about an amicable divorce.
I frequently hear that sometimes people don’t like or jibe with their marriage therapist and then stop going. If that happens, find someone else and keep changing therapists until you find a fit. The most important factor is, do you like and trust this person? Do you have a rapport with them? I must tell you, to this day, clients fire me, drop out, or switch to someone else; our profession is like hairdressers; we deal with many types of clientele, hair, and styling requests, and we can’t possibly please every customer. I’m used to it and never take it personally. We all want to be loved, of course, but I understand my style is not for everyone, and since the therapy is for you, my attitude is I want you to be happy.
Understanding hard and soft categories of marital disillusionment.
I have written in the past about marital crimes and how they have different levels, from misdemeanors to felonies and capital crimes. Therapists at Brigham Young University and the University of Minnesota who research marriages on the brink characterize reasons clients give for leaving as falling into soft or hard categories. The three “hard” issues or marital felonies, as I call them, are adultery, abuse, and addiction; in this case, they are most lethal when the spouse doing those things is not making or willing to put in a good faith effort to discontinue them or go into recovery. The soft category issues include growing apart, losing connection, losing romantic love, financial disagreements, being different people, and not paying enough attention. (4) The hard issues alone have enough destructive qualities to end a marriage. The soft issues can end marriages over time when not dealt with and improved.
In addition to this, the way we are wired and our tolerance level for living with another human being for life and all that brings are different. Soft thinkers are hopeful and optimistic types and far more tolerant of marriage’s challenges, while hard thinkers are less hopeful and are likely to consider divorce frequently. My last husband had to be the hardest thinker I have ever met. About five minutes after we married, It began to unfold that he was intolerant of me and at least one of my two children most of the time and quickly began to tell me that we would be divorced; it was just a matter of when. The whole thing seemed ludicrous at the time, but the energy of marriage can profoundly affect hard thinkers, and not in a good way. I think of hard thinkers as fair-weather partners who are generally difficult people and who may be impossible to please over the long haul.
Understand that I do think sometimes divorce is the right decision. I see couples sometimes and say to myself, “You need a mercy killing; end this madness, please.” I am saying, deal with your stuff and try to repair things if possible. If your partner is a reasonable, sane person, don’t keep a divorce decision secret from them for years before you plan to do it and spring it on them one fine day. If you want to leave, deal with it sooner rather than later; make sure you speak with a marriage therapist who can talk to you about whether your part in the situation and whether your thinking is solid and prepare the ground with respect and compassion so you may have a chance at an amicable divorce.
Married people think about divorce a lot.
A married person can sit in misery for a very long time before officially entering into the divorce process, according to statistics. In a report by the Institute of Family Studies (1) reported by Allen Hawkins and Sage Allen, where 3000 individuals married at least one year were surveyed, ranging between age 25 and 50, and more than half said they had thought of divorce at one time or another. The survey was part of the National Divorce Decision-Making Project, which asked a series of questions about what people think and do when considering divorce. In addition to the survey, the researchers interviewed a small sub-sample of respondents to get a more “fine-grained perspective.” (3)
One of the main takeaways of this study is that thinking about divorce does not necessarily lead to divorce, and thinking about it occasionally is normal. It also said that speaking with trusted people about the feelings and thoughts one is having about their marriage seems to help keep people in their marriages, though every marriage therapist knows that talking about your spouse to people your spouse also has a relationship with is often not helpful, and can poison the well. For example, if Sarah tells her mom about her frustrations with her husband, Steve, it will harm Steve’s relationship with his mother-in-law. If you do talk about your frustrations with someone, make sure they aren’t in your mutual circle of family or acquaintances.
What I want is for individuals who find themselves thinking of divorce and firmly in the marital deterioration process to speak up and get some form of assistance in stage two, erosion. Definitely get therapy yourself, and discuss with your therapist the best ways to tell your partner that you are struggling with the marriage. We know that getting individual therapy about marital distress is helpful in staving off divorce. Treat your spouse as you would want to be treated, and kindly and compassionately approach them and let them know how serious your feelings are. Give them an opportunity to make it right. In addition, do an honest and humble assessment of your part in why the marriage is on its knees, I promise you there are things there. Figuring out your part in it may be the best thing you can do for your family members.
Divorce regret.
There’s enough regret about divorce to mention it. The best data comes from when people look backward, 10 years later, after many situations have played out. Judith Wallerstein, who passed away in 2012 but was then executive director for the Center for the Family in Transition in Corte Madera, Calif., studied the effects of divorce for decades and followed 60 middle and upper-income families for ten years following divorce. Men, women, and children were interviewed in the study. (6) Among the ones who initiated the divorce, two-thirds claimed to be happier ten years later. Here are some of the other takeaways:
- Overall quality of life improved in 10 percent of the divorced couples.
- Divorce is more psychologically significant for women. Fifty-five percent of women had “notably improved the quality of their lives,” compared to 32 percent of men.
- Women’s ability to thrive depended on their age and profession at the time of divorce. Women under 40 fared better, based on psychological and financial measures. Seventy percent of the under-40 women improved their financial status, while 40 percent of the over-40 year-olds experienced a decline in income.
- Ten years later few people took responsibility for the marriage’s breakup. More than half the women took no responsibility at all.
Despite worsening conditions, very few wished to reconcile with their ex; of the 60 couples studied, two remarried one another, and one divorced again later. At the 10-year mark, 90 percent of women and 70 percent of men felt it had been the right decision.
The one factor that influenced this was the intense anger that remained 10 years later. Although the divorces studied were relatively amicable, there were no battles over custody or visitation; the research showed that couples were as angry many years later as at the time of the divorce. Ten years later, 40 percent of women and 28 percent of men remained intensely angry with their former partner. The tragic part of this statistic, Wallerstein said, was that women’s anger toward their ex spilled onto the child’s relationship with the father.
Children.
Wallerstein found that divorce was the central influencing factor, casting a shadow in children’s lives ten years later. The vivid memories and intense grief over long-ago infidelity by one parent or divorce occurring at such a young age, the child never got to know an intact family, and the pain of loss of close contact with a father who distanced himself in the post-divorce years. Although boys seemed to suffer more initially, girls seemed to exhibit negative symptoms of anxiety more in their adolescent years.
Children grieve the loss of their “first family.” (7). Children are expected to move along as their parents have, and for many, it feels as if they are supposed to lop off that period in their lives as if it didn’t exist.
Remarriage and stepfamilies have mostly negative effects on children, which makes complete sense. What a huge adjustment it would be for a child to be put in a situation of having to live in an entirely new family environment with completely different routines, rituals, and ways of doing things. There are so many factors that can lead to intense discomfort for children that it’s a wonder that any of these families succeed.
Adult Children of Divorce.
Gray divorce is a huge topic these days, and for those who raised their children and then parted, to think that the children will fare well after their parents’ divorce is misguided. In her book Primal Divorce: Adult Children of Divorce, author Leila Miller says when she researched her book, she was shocked at the avalanche of pain she encountered. Miller says adult children of divorce typically feel like they have lost a home to go to and learn to “navigate two separate worlds” and to be two different people, depending on which parent they are with. (8) In the end, Miller concluded that divorce is never over for the children who experience it.
Whether you have young children, adolescents, or grown children, divorce will have lasting effects, no matter when it occurs. Yes, some marriages need to end, some people can’t be healthy in a relationship with another, it’s true. But let’s be real about the damage it does, what a big deal it always is, and how long it takes to recover from it if one ever does.
(6) https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1985-06-14-vw-2440-story.html
(7) https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-adult-children-of-divorce-find-their-voice
(8) https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-adult-children-of-divorce-find-their-voice
We’ve got lots of news and exciting things going on in the relationship realm … so I’m preparing to send out a regular newsletter with the best relationship advice on the planet. To get on my email list, click here.
Becky Whetstone, Ph.D., is a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist in Arkansas and Texas* and is known as America’s Marriage Crisis Manager®. She is a former features writer and columnist for the San Antonio Express-News and has worked with thousands of couples to save their marriages. She can work with you, too, as a life coach if you’re not in Texas or Arkansas. She is also co-host of the YouTube Call Your Mother Relationship Show and has a telehealth private practice as a therapist and life coach via Zoom. To contact her, check out www.DoctorBecky.com and www.MarriageCrisisManager.com. Also, here is how to find her work on the Huffington Post. Don’t forget to follow her on Medium so you don’t miss a thing!
For licensure verification, find Becky Whetstone Cheairs.
When Your Spouse Wants to Leave and Refuses Therapy.
Chasing after and pursuing a partner on the brink of leaving you worsens things. Learn about what does help during this dicey and fragile time. Photo: Canva/Becky Whetstone.
Every week, I receive numerous phone calls and emails from people in a marriage crisis seeking advice. Almost always, the Leaning-in partner reaches out; this is the person whom their partner, The Decider, has told that they think they want out of the marriage and don’t want to go to marriage counseling, at least initially. For all of you in this terrible and frightening predicament, this blog is for you. For those of you in relationships that may one day lead to this experience, read up. There are many lessons to be learned from regretful Leaning-in partners in a marriage crisis who wonder if it’s too late to save their marriages.
The setup for the marriage crisis.
The story is the same almost every time. The Decider has been pointing out relationship problems for some time, maybe even asking to go for couples therapy, and for whatever reason, the Leaning-in partner didn’t take the requests seriously. This is always the fatal mistake, one we can all learn from. If your spouse gets annoyed and asks for change or something to be different, you better believe it is a big deal to them and they are serious. To dismiss them as a gripe or bitch shows arrogance and ignorance, plus a lack of insight, compassion, and respect.
Gripes and bitches become that way when their partner ignores their pleas; this must be clearly understood. A lack of response from their partner in any form and for any reason will plant cancer cells of disillusionment into the marriage’s bloodstream, where they will expand over time, creating a downward, destructive path leading to a marriage crisis. Put another way, the Decider resents and silently seethes, and the feelings worsen over time.
Leaning-in partners tell me they had reasons for not responding to their partner’s repeated requests for change. Either they didn’t think the situation was that bad (ignorance, lack of compassion), felt they could fix the problem alone (ignorance), had an inkling their spouse was barking but would never bite (ignorance), or felt going to a marriage counselor wasn’t for them (ignorance and arrogance). Yes, some people wrongly think they’re so smart they don’t need a trained professional’s assistance.
Marriage therapists are sometimes the Rodney Dangerfields of the mental health field; they get no respect. Becoming a marriage therapist is a long, hard path involving many years of school, reading hundreds of books, studying the research, being supervised for years, and spending thousands of hours of clinical client time. What could we know about relationships and marriages? As for me, I can’t believe how much there is to know about that, and I’m not even close to knowing it all. Understanding the dynamics of a healthy relationship with self and others is a learned skill, like snow skiing or tennis. If you have never had therapy, never studied relationship dynamics, and are just winging getting along with people, I can assure you that you are functioning at the pre-school level of relationship knowledge. I used to be there, too, and man, was I a mess.
If the two have gone to a couples therapist, they put little or no effort into the process and probably dropped out. Yes, friends, let me tell you right now, if you go to marriage therapy, it’s a major commitment; I’m sorry this comes as a shock for so many. How many times have I heard a Leaning-in partner say they went to marriage therapy but didn’t like the therapist or didn’t agree with what they said and then blew it off? They tell friends and family, “It didn’t work,” about marriage therapy, when the family therapist knows it was the couple that didn’t put in the work. There are no quick fixes. You will spend time, focus, and dedication; you must have an open mind and good attitude to do it right and be willing to take all the blame, even if it’s not all on you. Like going to college, the studying and reading part ain’t fun; it can be a grind, and parts of it you will hate, but you do it for the ultimate rewards it will bring, a concept known as delayed gratification. Only people with an adult mindset can tolerate the hard work on the front end for the higher good to come. Childish adults want the immediate, easier payoff.
In an era where dinner and groceries are easily delivered, some clients want marriage therapy and relationship skills spoon-fed to them, like porridge to a baby. Sorry, but you’ll have to go to the store, pick out the food, bring it home, heat it up, serve it, eat it, and clean it up afterward. Marriage therapy is for big boys and girls.
When their lives are on the line, few cancer patients believe they know better than the cancer specialist about treatment plans designed for cure or survival, but when it comes to couples counseling and those of us who work in marriage crisis management, we don’t get the respect cancer doctors do. I guess if we aren’t offering surgery, pills, medicine, and other tangible interventions, people have a hard time understanding its value. I always tell Leaning-in partners that when a couple doesn’t use a specialist to help them through these days of nervous system activations, fear, and mistrust, the result will be like a cat driving a car: you’ll weave all over the road doing damage as you go, then, ultimately, drive off a cliff. If a couple wants to go through traumatic experiences and act like foolish jackasses during a marriage crisis, that’s their business, but when kids are involved, the ones who will surely pay a heavy price for their parent’s ridiculousness, I am up for a fight.
I have an insatiable need to thoroughly understand marriages, relationships, and the marriage crisis dynamic, always seeking the intelligent, best way to do or say what will stop couples from tearing up their lives and the well-being of their children. I have worked with thousands of couples in crisis over the years, researching and writing about it, and yet, I still encounter those who think I am full of it and don’t know what I’m talking about. I’m not saying I know it all, or my information is the best there is, to each his own, of course, but I’m always curious: who do they believe does know?
I think one reason the cancer doctor’s advice is taken to heart, and some reject the marriage therapist, or at least decide the process isn’t for them, besides the intangibles I mentioned above, is that the therapist must address a person’s perspective, character, humanity, beliefs, values, behaviors, and other areas that are sensitive and subject to toxic shame provoking feelings the person would prefer not to have. No one enjoys being told they’ve been acting like an arrogant asshole or that what they are doing is completely dysfunctional, but a good therapist can deliver that message without the sting unskilled people do. However, no matter how skilled a therapist is, painful truths must be faced, and humility is the only antidote for that. What do I mean? Maybe you need to hear and face what you do in relationships that don’t work, understand their whys, and work to correct them. That takes courage and a willingness to accept that you are imperfect and flawed, just like everyone else.
Do-it-your-selfers in marriage crisis.
Those who don’t like the news a marriage therapist delivers often create their own next step based on their beliefs and ideas about what is going on, whether correct or not. They may go to other therapists for validation and often search the Internet for gurus and advisors who are on the same page. “Your cancer is easily cured; just pay me, X,” for example. Back when I was in a marriage crisis and in the Decider position, my soon-to-be ex perpetuated the story that I had lost my mind and never said a word about how he had failed me as a partner. He sought answers that fit his theory about himself and us because he didn’t want to believe that a smart, intelligent, and super-successful man like himself could be the opposite of that in relationships.
Those who don’t like what a marriage therapist has to say about their part in a relationship may obsessively copy links to articles and YouTube videos and send them around to get people, especially their estranged partners, to get them to understand their side. This phenomenon reminds me of seeing TV star Farrah Fawcett in a documentary called “Farrah’s Story,” a difficult topic about her two-and-a-half-year fight against anal cancer that ended in her death in 2009. Determined to avoid surgery that would leave her with a permanent colostomy bag, perhaps her only hope, she searched for miracles and alternative treatments and felt as if she’d found it in Germany, where doctors at a hospital there told her they would remove all her cancer using an excruciatingly painful treatment called, chemoembolization. She went six times and was declared by the Germans to be cancer-free over and over, only to find soon after that the cancer was still there and spreading. I remember watching it in horror, knowing she was playing the fool’s game and causing herself unnecessary suffering, but she just didn’t want to accept the reality of her situation, what her cancer doctors had told her would be her best option, and thought she could find something better.
Steve Jobs was another who rejected what was initially suggested as a treatment, surgery, for an often-cured and rare form of pancreatic cancer and felt he knew better, but his decisions early on failed him later on. My message to you is to approach your marriage crisis humbly, admit that you don’t know much, if anything, about it or how to have a healthy marriage or relationship, and that you might benefit from listening to someone who does. Humility saves couples in marriage crisis; pride, ego, and arrogance take them down.
The first thing to do.
The first step in any marriage crisis is to stabilize the situation. Immediately after the initial revelation that the Decider wants to leave or is seriously considering leaving, a couple’s sympathetic nervous systems activate, and their brains enter a full survival and life-threat mode. In this state of mind, you must think of it like a person’s IQ drops by 20 or more points, although that is not what really happens. When a person’s sympathetic nervous system is activated, their cognitive abilities are offline; they act on impulse, things are done that are ugly, unhealthy behaviors, and unnecessary damage occurs. During this period there is a high potential to make things worse, so that is why we must create a plan to stop it. So, how do we stabilize a couple in such a situation?
The Decider’s brain tells them their life is in danger, though it isn’t, and their instinct says to run. What the Decider is running from is the Leaning-in partner. In this state, they imagine that if they stay around the Leaning-in partner, they will die, though they won’t. Meanwhile, the Leaning-in Partner’s brain is feeling a threat, too, and their brain tells them to fight, and to them, fighting means chasing after the Decider and desperately trying to pull them back into the marriage.
Unfortunately, if the Leaning-in partner chases the Decider, it will continue the activation, and they will want to run even further away. To create an opportunity to stabilize the crisis, the Leaning-in partner must rule against their instinct, make themselves stop the pursuit, and spend their energy instead on their own physical, mental, and emotional health. Instead of looking at what the Decider is doing, they must focus on themselves and what they need to change. This is the only healthy way to get out of the terrible feelings that come with a marriage crisis.
If the Leaning-in partner can give the Decider time and space, the Decider may be able to become calm again, where their rational thinking can be accessed. To do this, the Leaning-in Partner must stop all actions that are defined as pursuit, which includes begging, promises, flowers, sending links and videos, email and texting, show-and-tell stories about all the books you’ve read and things you’re doing and have realized, and all other attempts at changing the Decider’s mind. The Decider must be left alone. This initial crisis is like a storm, and we need the storm to quiet down; we must let the dust settle and then see what remains. In short, we need space and time, and major decisions slowed down. Whether a managed separation is appropriate for your situation should be decided with a marriage crisis therapist. If you do separate, it will have a purpose, guidelines, and timeline, and your marriage crisis specialist should oversee it.
If you cannot or will not take my wise advice about leaving the Decider alone and you decide to manage your marital cancer yourself, possibly believing you know best, then the chances that your spouse will choose divorce are extremely high, if not certain. It is the most important, crucial thing any Leaning-in partner can do at this point in a marriage crisis.
Next steps.
The next step is to visit a marriage and family therapist, one well-versed in the dynamics of a marriage crisis. Time and again, Leaning-partners tell me the Decider is in a state of mind where they have no interest in marriage therapy. If your partner won’t go, go by yourself. There are things you need to learn and understand, I assure you. Anyway, marriage crisis counseling and managing a marriage crisis are not to be confused with marriage counseling, whose goal is to repair and heal an injured marriage and to re-establish connection. In a marriage crisis, repairing and healing are off the table for the foreseeable future, and the sole goal is to manage the crisis. This is needed for several reasons: To prevent more damage and to stabilize two people who aren’t currently in a state of mind where great decisions are made.
When you meet with your marriage crisis manager, the therapist will pay attention to what you do and say and tell you when your thinking and processing are off or need examining. This applies to both partners. We want to make sure that when you are thinking and processing, you are doing it in the healthiest possible way, dealing with facts and evidence-based truths, not conjecture, fears, or made-up crap. We will point you away from dysfunctional thinking and toward wise processing and decision-making.
The best thing any couple can do is understand that slowing down the process and any decision-making about the future of the marriage is in the best interest of all involved, especially if children are involved. We want a couple to be able to get through this feeling they have done all they could, whether the marriage survives or not and have few, if any, regrets.
My partner will not go to marriage therapy or seek marriage crisis management.
If your partner will not involve themself in marriage crisis counseling, your only choice is to focus on getting as healthy as you can, yourself, and continue to leave your partner alone. Get individual counseling. As far as what you must do, you must approach your part in the marital problems with humility and fully understand why your partner became disillusioned with you as a partner, whether you believe their feelings are justified or not. Do not share with them what you are learning; do not tell them what you are doing. Just do it. They will see it, and they will notice. Do not be pitiful; do not make excuses; do not play the victim. Deciders don’t reconcile with weak and pitiful victims; they reconcile with strong, resilient, determined, action-oriented heroes. Be mysterious, and do the work. Blabbing reflects badly on you and does damage as far as the crisis is concerned, so don’t.
If you do what I am telling you, there is a chance your partner will want to give marriage another shot. This will be the time to insist on marriage counseling, where both of you will address your parts in your previous marital disaster. If neither one of you addresses these things, and you get divorced, then I predict that you will repeat the same patterns in a new relationship and may even face a marriage crisis once again. I hope that sounds like entering the Twilight Zone to you and that you do all in your power to correct your relationship mistakes and perspective so you can actually have the kind of partnership we all desire.
Some people get back together and break up numerous times during a marriage crisis. Reconciliation is rarely successful unless both partners work on the dysfunctional thinking and behaviors that got them in the situation in the first place. If you go back because single life and parenting sucked, you were financially strapped, couldn’t afford a decent place, or couldn’t attract the type of date you’d hoped; your reunification will be disastrous. You must repair your dysfunctional thinking and behaviors, and your motivation for wanting to return must be because you love and miss your partner.
No matter what happens, do the work.
You will end up divorced without making long overdue, permanent, and positive changes in your life. Have I said this enough times? Don’t assess and attempt to repair your problems yourself, like a doctor operating on himself. Get professional help. This is an absolutely crucial point. If you are lucky enough to have a chance at reconciliation, it will fail if you fall back into your old ways.
Back in the day, when I knew I needed to make a change in my life, I went to therapy and weekend workshops and sought out every opportunity for learning, healing, and growth; you have to believe with all of your heart that what you are doing is better for you. Hopefully, you will notice how much better you feel, and you will continue learning and growing no matter what happens. Even in my own life, I always look for ways to improve and learn more. The journey to health, well-being, and having healthy relationships with yourself and others never ends. None of us will ever know all there is to know. If you are motivated solely to get your partner back, you have much more growth and learning to do.
I hate divorce more than anything in the world, but sometimes it is for the best. Where the rubber meets the pavement is: can a person grow up mentally and emotionally and work to change? Some people have serious mental disorders and cannot change their negative patterns of thinking and behavior. Those marriages won’t, and perhaps shouldn’t, be saved. The good news is that 90 percent of humans don’t have disorders like that.
If you ultimately divorce.
When a couple is in a marriage crisis, things are dire. The odds are against repair and reconciliation. I have created the marriage crisis intervention to stabilize the crazy time and damage often done and get people to a place where they can make wise decisions. If, in the end, the Decider still wants to divorce, it doesn’t end there, and there is still more work to do.
We need you to be part of the change I hope to lead in how we marry and divorce and refuse to go nasty. People say they want an amicable divorce but don’t know how to attain it. I have created a plan for that, and I urge you to use it so that your entire family system can come through this sad end in the healthiest possible way, where respectful co-parenting exists. You will always be a family, no matter what. If divorce is inevitable, be part of the new divorce where the family’s mental and emotional health is considered, and families who part glide apart slowly, easily, and respectfully.
Finding my plans for managed separation and amicable divorce.
To find my plan for managed separation for couples hoping to reconcile, click here. To find my plan for managed separation for those planning to divorce, click here.
Check out my new ebook on marriage crisis and how to know if you need to separate. It also includes a plan for an amicable divorce.
We’ve got lots of news and exciting things going on in the relationship realm … so I’m preparing to send out a regular newsletter with the best relationship advice on the planet. To get on my email list, click here.
Becky Whetstone, Ph.D., is a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist in Arkansas and Texas* and is known as America’s Marriage Crisis Manager®. She is a former features writer and columnist for the San Antonio Express-News and has worked with thousands of couples to save their marriages. She can work with you, too, as a life coach if you’re not in Texas or Arkansas. She is also co-host of the YouTube Call Your Mother Relationship Show and has a telehealth private practice as a therapist and life coach via Zoom. To contact her, check out www.DoctorBecky.com and www.MarriageCrisisManager.com. Also, here is how to find her work on the Huffington Post. Don’t forget to follow her on Medium so you don’t miss a thing!
For licensure verification, find Becky Whetstone Cheairs.