Harry and Meghan: How did it Come to This?

A family therapist takes a look at the royal family’s problems.

Like many, I’m fatigued from the continuing saga of the British royal family, the feuds, gossip, estrangements, and bucketloads of first world problems. But as a marriage and family therapist, I see some gold to be mined.

Hopefully no one is surprised that the Meghan and Harry debacle resulted in anything but their semi-exile from the royal family, but do I think it was a display of functional family dynamics? Of course not. I assure you that if the royal family has a person trained in healthy family dynamics on their payroll, they are ignoring their advice.

What do healthy families look like? Think in terms of transparency, being genuine, loving and accepting of one another, kindness, supportive, compassionate, flexibile … those sorts of rare things. Unfortunately, I see this family as reacting and living primarily out of fear of what might happen, which is never a good idea, as so often the things we worried about never come to pass. Fearful action often undermines decision making that could benefit the whole family, instead of just an institution and the most powerful family members, the heirs to the throne. The better idea in families is always love and acceptance based.

Here is what I see:

· You have one of the most conservative, white, privileged families on the planet with more power and money than most of us can imagine. Due to inheritance, they have palaces, servants, priceless jewelry, fancy clothes, power, access to anyone in the world, chauffeurs, security and more, but it is all enabled at the pleasure of the British people. This family is highly motivated not to lose a good thing.

· Throughout the last 90 years, the royal family’s drama has tested the patience of the populace, beginning with the abdication of King Edward VIII in 1936 so he could marry the woman he loved. For those of you that don’t know, Britain’s sovereign is head of the Church of England, and in 1936 that meant the King had to follow strict, conservative, royal doctrine, which stated that an heir to the throne must marry an untainted, aka virginal woman. Edward’s choice, Wallis Simpson, had been married and divorced twice, which was quite scandalous in the day.

· When Edward abdicated, he became a pariah in his family and was given an allowance and exiled to France. His family had almost no contact with him after that, including his own mother, Queen Mary. The lesson: Don’t do anything to rock the family business or we will shun you forever. Your actions will be held over the family’s head for decades to come of how not to act. Business over blood, to the end.

· Since then, the overriding cloud hanging over the royal family has been … don’t do anything that might screw up the monarchy. Any prominent family member who says or does anything that threatens the family business, is subject to loss of power, position, protection, and potential exile and banishment.

Since Edward’s abdication and exile over 80 years ago, not much has changed when it comes to receiving the benefits royal life has to offer. The only softening of position over the years I can remember has been to allow first born girls to become Queen, even if a son is born afterward, and yes, you may now marry a divorced person and still become sovereign.

For the core group of working royals, however, it is still, “go along, follow the rules, do nothing controversial, and you may reap the family’s many rewards.” Problem is, the royal family has made a deal with the devil in that to maintain the viability of the crown and its institution, they have, will and continue to throw anyone and everyone, family or not, under the ornate eight-horse-drawn Gold State Coach to be trampled if they don’t follow the rules and do as they’re told, no matter how miserable the circumstances are that you’re subjected to — think Fergie, Diana, both famous beyond words, left to fend for themselves.

Healthy families exhibit loyalty and support to one another, even when in disagreement. The more strict, rigid and controlling a family is, the more dysfunctional it will be. Mired in rules and protocol, the royal family black sheep will be cast out like lepers. One of the most recent examples is Prince Andrew, the Queen’s son, who was accused of criminal behavior in allegedly having had sex with an underage woman. The harsh consequences Prince Andrew has endured, loss of titles, income, status as a working royal, make sense considering his actions.

But then there is Harry and Meghan, who have done nothing illegal. They simply decided to change their lives to escape the bullying and badgering of the British tabloid press, but only after their family refused to help. There was no compassion or empathy for how hard it is for anyone to assimilate into the world-famous fishbowl of scrutiny the royal family attracts, much less an American actress and biracial working royal.

Where King Charles and William, the Prince of Wales erred, in my opinion, is not adapting to the needs of individuals in their family in the 21st century. If the King’s youngest grown son, a working royal, has a wife who happens to be biracial and comes under continual attack by a blood thirsty press, reminiscent of his mother Princess Diana so long ago, why not rally around her showing compassion and caring? Why not have her and Harry’s back and get it right this once, protect her and get the struggling family members all the help you can muster with the power and money you possess?

In the recent Netflix special, Harry described being continually surprised by the you’re on your own attitude of his brother and father, the ones who stand to lose the most in any royal scandal. No compromise was offered, Harry and Meghan had to suck-it-up-buttercup, and if you’re not in, you’re out.

Harry chose to remove his family from what he perceived as racism, personal attack, inaccurate and sensationalistic reporting, and lack of support and assistance. He took his new family to Canada, part of the Commonwealth, where he could still operate as a working royal, and then to California after his family denied Harry’s request that he and Meghan be able to continue their roles as working royals on a part time basis.

At the time I had hoped they would work something out that worked for everyone, but it was not to be. Just like in 1936, it’s “Full time working royal or not at all,” and in their decision to cut Harry and Meghan out of the royal pie, the family missed an opportunity to bring diversity to an institution that looks, lives and acts little like the Commonwealth it represents.

The biggest error of all, in the end, was the lifting of financial support and police protection, leaving Harry, who is one of the most famous and hounded people in the world because of who his parents are, left to fend for himself. Unfortunately, Harry is keenly aware of the dangers of being a famous royal without police protection.

When a person feels they have nothing to lose, because they have already lost everything they feared losing, they are then free, and will do what they must to survive. Further, when the people you love and grew up with turn their back on you, all bets are off in family dynamics. The question becomes, “They did not protect you, should you then protect them?”

Harry and Meghan had to raise huge funds to support the expensive lifestyle they must lead, because that is what protects them — a heavily guarded and secured inaccessible home in which to live, and protection when moving about. The most valuable asset Harry and Meghan possess is their story, and so they told at least part of it for a fee, and the portrait they painted of life inside the palace is less than flattering. Not a surprise, a lot of true stories about families are that way.

Perhaps having the truth told will wake the royal family up to a much-needed position of softening, flexibility, and compassion, but I doubt it. Family business over family well-being was the choice before, and it’s the choice now, the royal family doesn’t seem to learn much from past family history … but they might one day, when the British people finally tire of watching the royal family devour their own.

“Doctor Becky” Whetstone, Ph.D. (her legal name is Becky Whetstone Cheairs) is a Marriage and Family Therapist in Arkansas and Texas. She sees clients by appointment and hosts the You Tube Channel ‘Call Your Mother’ with her daughter, Casey Marie Schmidt. Learn more or contact her at www.doctorbecky.com.

British Royal Family

Harry And Meghan

Princess Diana

Therapist Advice

Dysfunctional Family

Why I Thank the Worst Boss I Ever Had

She led me to know that I had to become self-employed.

The New York Times published an article recently No More Working for Jerks ! about how our workplace culture is changing and employees will not tolerate toxic bosses anymore. All I could says was, “How come it took so long?” Back when I worked in a large business, the corporate attitude was to accept the soul-killing reality of a toxic boss, and keep producing as if we were loving every minute.

In 1997 it all came to a head for me.

I married a politician while I was a feature writer and twice-a-week columnist for the San Antonio Express-News. Writing the column was a dream, and I tolerated workplace bullying and sexual harassment to continue doing it. My features editor was always supportive and encouraging, and that helped. In the late winter of 1996, however, she was replaced with Elaine Ayala, who immediately told me she was going to “Teach me how to write.”

I didn’t know anything about Elaine before the day she arrived, except that she was fairly new in the newsroom and had spent months trying to get reporters to enter their work in contests. As she arranged her desk on her first day, she asked me a question about the department workings, and when I answered, she snapped, “I already knew that (roll eyes)!”

We turned in digital and hard copies of our stories. I’d come back from lunch with a hard copy thrown in my chair, marked up in red flair pen with big red circles and 2-inch words like, “No!” written at the top. In January 1997 I covered the presidential inauguration and Elaine said, “Make me proud.” I froze in the nation’s capital while digging for stories that made the front page. She never said a word to me about it. I got depressed, started having panic attacks, and then, writer’s block. For the first time I missed deadlines, and felt powerless to do anything about it.

In May I married the politician and they took my one reason for tolerating the baloney away — my column. I went to the big cheese editor and told them I could not work for Elaine, to please move me to news or have someone else oversee my work. They denied my request, telling me I was a born feature writer and had to stay, so I resigned, fearing that I would die if I did not. As I packed my things, Elaine watched. She came up to me and said, “You never respected me.” “Hmm,” I thought, “I wonder why?”

I did not say anything in return, but wish I had. Respect is earned, of course, and when I had bosses who bestowed positive vibes, I’d do most anything for them. I wonder how my life would have been different had Elaine Ayala not entered my world, or if I had known better about how to handle it.

I have grown and matured a lot since then and sometimes fantasize about handling things differently. Still, the grief and disappointment of leaving the paper helped me know one thing about myself: I had to situate myself where I would be permanently self-employed. Never would my career be in anyone else’s hands. It took a few years to get there, but I am grateful to Elaine for showing me how one toxic manager can change the course of a person’s life in a positive way, if we will arrange it that way. I am so happy, thrilled, ecstatic that employees in 2022 are not enabling arrogance and contempt from their bosses. It’s a cultural shift that needed to happen.

Becky Whetstone has a doctorate in Marriage & Family Therapy from St. Mary’s University in San Antonio, Texas. She has a telehealth private practice and continues to write features on her blog. www.DoctorBecky.com

NYTIMES.COM

If You Want to Keep your Relationship, Stop Doing These Three Things Now.

Relationships are for adults, and adults control themselves.

Working with couples over many years reveals how little people know about healthy communication, but of course, most people know this. The idea is to send your message to the listener, have the message received and processed accurately with a result of mutual understanding. Sounds very simple, but almost no one can do it.

Why?

In short, it’s the subject, words, tone and timing we choose that leads to problems, combined with poor self-esteem. Someone with a solid and positive sense of self will have a wider tolerance to hear constructive complaints than one who perceives themselves as inferior. With those feeling not good enough, perceived negative scrutiny can be as emotionally painful as a knife through the heart. When that happens it is called a trauma response, which is a physiological activation where the brain perceives a threat. The heart starts to race, blood pressure rises and digestion stops as the listener goes into fight, flight, or freeze. Though this activation and threat response points out that an old painful theme from their past is being brought to the forefront, most people have no idea this is what’s going on. All they know is something said that sent them off and unless circumvented, the person will either lash out, run off, or freeze up. Communication then shuts down and damage will be done. Once this pattern is underway in a relationship, it will discourage future attempts to speak out, and so the pattern of “we can’t communicate” begins.

While trauma therapy helps people figure out what their trigger subjects are and takes people through a process of eliminating the emotional pain associated with them, what you can do in the meantime involves controlling yourself when you get activated and go into the fight, flight or freeze threat response. This means controlling the part of you that wants to thrash, leave or go mute and respond from the best part of yourself. The adult self.

So if my husband riles me up, my impulse might be to verbally throttle him, but instead I slow my response down and say something like, “Wow, what you said really hurt my feelings.” You have to say something, otherwise you are just falling into a freeze response and holding in and storing the negative energy that comes with it.

There are a few tips that can help keep your favorite listener from getting activated in the first place, and practicing them will serve you well …

Choose your words deliberately and carefully, and don’t do the following:

Examples:

1. Don’t use all-or-nothing words and phrasing like …. never, don’t, always …

“You don’t listen!”

“You don’t care!”

“You always …”

“You never …”

In all the years I’ve done couples and family therapy, I’ve never met a partner who doesn’t care, doesn’t listen, or is guilty of always or never doing XY or Z one hundred percent of the time. Talking in absolutes and mischaracterizing your partner in this way succeeds in only one thing: Getting them to disregard everything you say after that. People tend to shut down or become defensive when the accusation tossed is flat-out not true.

To get people to listen and respond, you must be precise and accurate about what you’re pointing out; instead of, “You don’t listen,” you could say, “I feel like you might not be listening when I talk because you don’t respond. I’m missing something, right?” Clarifying before reacting is crucial. Taking this wise advice will mean the difference between acting like a belligerent teenager or an adult. If you’re riled up during a conversation, stop what you’re doing, ask for a 20-minute timeout, calm yourself down and return and work it out via adult conversations that are considerate and respectful. If you’ve ever wondered what adulting is, know that it is controlling yourself.

2. Unless complimenting or praising another, do not begin a critique, or any sentence, with the word, “You.” (See examples above).

When you begin a sentence with the word “You,” the listener’s brain often goes on criticism alert. Criticism kills relationships, so we need to not do it. It’s best to talk about what you’re experiencing when the person does the thing that annoys you.

Examples:

Don’t tell me I’m always late. Instead tell me it makes you nervous when I’m not on time.

Don’t tell me you despise when I drink too much, tell me you’re not attracted to me when I drink too much.

Don’ tell me I don’t care, because I do. Instead tell me that sometimes you feel disconnected because you haven’t had enough (Fill in the blank) attention, quality time, affection, sex, help, flirting, etc.

When you choose your words accurately and phrase them in a way that doesn’t sound like finger-pointing, most reasonable humans will listen and work to meet your needs.

3. Another disastrous way couples communicate is by going scorched earth, which is the use of relationship and love-ending language. This should never be done unless you really mean it.

Examples:

“I am done!”

“I want a divorce!”

“I hate you!”

We all get angry in our relationships, that part is normal. What isn’t normal — or healthy, is to talk in drastic terms that you don’t really mean. From your side, you want to wound the other person, perhaps because they wounded you, but this is childish thinking. Look deeper at what’s going on, a partner who feels unheard or disregarded eventually reaches a crescendo of stress and explodes with verbal shrapnel or some sort of dysfunctional reaction. This is the worst time to talk about your feelings or anything else. It’s far better to calm down, then come back and calmly discuss what isn’t working. This is when we can access the better part of our personality. I train my clients to understand that things said while a person is highly activated are usually extreme exaggerations and don’t represent how the person truly feels. If they spoke accurately, they’d say something like “In this moment I am so angry with you that I feel like I’m done, but I know that I’m not.”

Using relationship or love-ending language strikes at every human’s worst fears — rejection and abandonment, and I promise you a bad result if you say things like this without meaning it. Some things once said, cannot be unheard or unremembered. This also goes along with talking cruelly about them as a human being or their physical features. Someone I know once became furious with her partner and told him he had a crooked little penis. That was a lethal blow from which they could not recover. If you can’t see anything wrong with that, as this person couldn’t, “It’s not wrong because it’s true,” she said, then you really do have deeper issues than a self-help blog can offer.

Becky Whetstone, Ph.D., LMFT, LPC, PSEP, is a Marriage & Family Therapist in Little Rock, Arkansas and does telehealth as a therapist and life coach all over the USA. To contact her visit her website at www.DoctorBecky.com or email becky@DoctorBecky.com.